I Ranked for Keywords Miles Away.Then I Checked My Address.
Proximity in local SEO isn't a binary thing. I was staring at rankings for a plumbing client in Melbourne, seeing results from Cocoa Beach and Palm Bay, and wondering why we weren't dominating closer searches. Turns out Google's proximity algorithm considers the searcher's location, not just your business address. A search from someone in Titusville pulls different results than the same search from someone in Brevard County five miles over.
What I missed at first: your address matters, but it's weighted against where people are actually searching from. Google's local search documentation confirms this. The closer your business is to the searcher's location or intent, the better your visibility. But "closer" is relative. A home service business with a service area covering multiple cities can still rank well if the searcher is within that radius.
The real leverage isn't your address alone. It's how clearly you signal your service area and how Google interprets that against search location data. Our SEO approach accounts for this by mapping service areas properly and making location signals explicit in your content and schema markup.
Worth trying: Check your Google Business Profile's service area setting. If it's blank or too narrow, update it to match where you actually work. Then pull up a search from a different city and see what changes in the results.
